When Minnesota and Wisconsin homeowners face the critical decision of choosing between metal roofing and asphalt shingles, the question “Is metal roofing cheaper than shingles?” becomes paramount. At Miller’s Roofing & Siding, we’ve helped countless homeowners navigate this important investment since 1990. While metal roofs require a higher initial cost, they often provide superior long-term value through exceptional durability and energy savings. Understanding the complete cost comparison helps you make an informed decision about protecting your home and family.
Why Roof Costs Matter for Minnesota and Wisconsin Homeowners
Your roof serves as your home’s first line of defense against our region’s harsh weather conditions. Making the right choice between metal roofing and shingles affects not only your immediate budget but also your long-term financial planning. Minnesota and Wisconsin’s brutal winters, with heavy snow loads, ice dam formation, and severe storms, make selecting the right roofing materials particularly crucial for homeowners in our service areas.
At Miller’s Roofing & Siding, we understand that the total cost of ownership extends far beyond the initial installation price. Factors like maintenance requirements, energy efficiency, warranty coverage, and replacement frequency all contribute to your roof’s lifetime value—which is why we use only premium materials from industry-leading manufacturers like GAF, CertainTeed, Tamko, and Owens Corning.
Metal Roof vs Shingles: Understanding the Key Differences
Metal roofs and asphalt shingles differ significantly in composition, installation methods, and performance characteristics. Metal roofing typically consists of steel or aluminum panels designed to interlock seamlessly, creating a weather-tight barrier that excels in Minnesota and Wisconsin’s challenging climate. Standing seam metal roofs feature raised seams that run vertically, providing exceptional protection against our region’s severe weather conditions.
Our team at Miller’s Roofing & Siding specializes in installing premium metal roofing systems from trusted partners like EDCO Roofing and Dakota Steel Roofing. These systems are engineered to handle everything from heavy snow loads to severe hailstorms that frequently impact our service areas.
Asphalt shingles, the most common roofing material in the U.S., consist of a fiberglass or organic mat base coated with asphalt and topped with ceramic granules. Miller’s Roofing & Siding exclusively installs high-quality asphalt shingles from manufacturers like GAF, CertainTeed, and Tamko, ensuring these individual shingles overlap properly to create an effective protective layer.
Understanding Roof Materials and Costs
Asphalt Shingle Roof: Proven and Affordable
Asphalt shingle roofs dominate the residential roofing market due to their affordability and versatility. At Miller’s Roofing & Siding, we offer both three-tab and architectural shingles, with architectural shingles being our most popular choice for Minnesota and Wisconsin homes. The type of asphalt shingle you choose significantly impacts both initial cost and long-term performance.
Basic three-tab shingles cost less upfront but may require more frequent replacement in our harsh climate. Architectural shingles, while more expensive initially, provide superior wind resistance and longer warranties—particularly important for homes facing our region’s challenging weather conditions. Our partnerships with GAF, CertainTeed, and Tamko ensure you receive industry-leading warranties that provide genuine peace of mind.
Metal Roof Materials: Steel and Aluminum Excellence
Metal roofing materials vary in cost and performance characteristics, and Miller’s Roofing & Siding offers premium options to meet every need and budget. Steel roofing, often galvanized or coated with protective finishes, offers exceptional durability at moderate cost. Our EDCO and Dakota Steel systems provide outstanding protection against Minnesota and Wisconsin’s extreme weather.
Aluminum roofing, while more expensive, provides superior corrosion resistance—especially beneficial in areas with heavy snow and ice exposure. Standing seam metal roofs represent the premium option, featuring concealed fasteners and superior weather protection that our employee-based installation crews install with precision and expertise.
Metal Roof Cost vs Shingles Cost Analysis
Average Shingle Roof Cost with Miller’s Roofing & Siding
Asphalt shingle roof installation through Miller’s Roofing & Siding typically provides exceptional value, with costs varying based on shingle quality, roof complexity, and specific project requirements. Our architectural shingles from GAF, CertainTeed, and Tamko offer superior performance and come with industry-leading warranties that protect your investment.
These costs include premium materials, expert installation by our employee-based crews (no subcontractors), comprehensive warranties, and all necessary accessories like high-quality underlayment and flashing. Our EPA Lead-Safe certification ensures safe, compliant installation that meets all regulatory requirements.
Average Cost of a Metal Roof Installation
A new metal roof installation by Miller’s Roofing & Siding represents a premium investment that delivers decades of protection and peace of mind. Our metal roofing systems from EDCO and Dakota Steel are engineered for Minnesota and Wisconsin’s demanding climate, with installations performed exclusively by our trained employee crews.
While the initial cost of metal roofing exceeds asphalt shingles substantially, this investment often pays significant dividends through reduced maintenance needs, enhanced energy efficiency, and exceptional longevity that can span 40-70 years.
Cost Factors That Influence Your Roofing Investment
Miller’s Roofing & Siding considers several key factors when providing your detailed cost estimate:
Roof Size and Complexity: Larger roofs with multiple angles, dormers, or chimneys require more materials and skilled labor, affecting overall project costs.
Material Quality: We exclusively use premium materials from trusted manufacturers, ensuring superior warranties and extended service life that justify the investment.
Installation Requirements: Our thorough inspections identify needs like existing roof removal, structural repairs, or ventilation system upgrades that contribute to total project costs.
Regional Considerations: As a local Minnesota and Wisconsin company, we understand regional labor costs, material availability, and specific climate challenges that affect your project.
Is Metal Roofing Cheaper Than Shingles in the Long Run?
While metal roofs cost more upfront, they often prove more economical over time—a fact we’ve observed throughout our 30+ years serving Minnesota and Wisconsin homeowners. A quality metal roof installed by Miller’s Roofing & Siding can last 40 to 70 years, while even premium asphalt shingles typically require replacement every 20 to 30 years in our harsh climate.
This longevity means homeowners may replace an asphalt shingle roof two or three times during a single metal roof’s lifespan, making the long-term cost comparison favor metal roofing significantly.
Energy efficiency also contributes to substantial long-term savings. Metal roofs reflect solar heat effectively, potentially reducing cooling costs by 10% to 25%. Combined with Miller’s Roofing & Siding’s expert installation and minimal maintenance requirements, these benefits help offset the higher initial investment while providing decades of reliable protection.
Pros and Cons of Metal Roofs and Shingles
Pros and Cons of Metal Roofing
Advantages of Metal Roofing:
- Exceptional durability lasting 40+ years with minimal maintenance
- Superior weather resistance against wind, hail, and heavy snow loads
- Outstanding energy-efficient properties that reduce heating and cooling costs
- Fire resistance and pest protection for enhanced home security
- Enhanced resale value that recovers up to 95% of installation costs
- Recyclable materials supporting environmental sustainability
Disadvantages of Metal Roofing:
- Higher upfront installation investment compared to asphalt shingles
- Potential for increased noise during heavy rain or hail (though modern installations minimize this)
- Natural expansion and contraction with temperature changes
- Requires experienced installation crews like Miller’s employee-based teams
Pros and Cons of Asphalt Shingles
Advantages of Asphalt Shingles:
- Lower initial installation cost makes roofing accessible to more budgets
- Wide variety of colors and styles available to complement any architectural design
- Proven installation process familiar to experienced contractors like Miller’s teams
- Readily available replacement materials for future repairs
- Excellent performance in most weather conditions when properly installed
Disadvantages of Asphalt Shingles:
- Shorter lifespan requires more frequent replacement, especially in harsh climates
- Susceptible to wind damage and granule loss during severe storms
- Higher cumulative maintenance and replacement costs over decades
- Less energy-efficient than metal alternatives
- Greater environmental impact from more frequent replacements
Choosing Between a Metal Roof and a Shingle Roof
Your decision should consider both immediate budget constraints and long-term financial goals. Miller’s Roofing & Siding helps homeowners evaluate these factors honestly, prioritizing their needs over sales pressure. Homeowners planning to stay in their homes for decades often benefit from metal roofing’s superior longevity and minimal maintenance requirements.
Those with tighter budgets or shorter-term housing plans might prefer our premium architectural shingles’ lower initial cost while still receiving exceptional quality and comprehensive warranties from industry-leading manufacturers.
Climate considerations play a crucial role in Minnesota and Wisconsin. Our region’s harsh winters, heavy snow loads, and severe storms favor metal roofing’s superior snow-shedding capabilities and resistance to ice dam formation—benefits we’ve witnessed firsthand throughout decades of local service.
Cost Comparison: Overall Value Assessment
Durability and Maintenance Costs
Metal roofs installed by Miller’s Roofing & Siding require minimal maintenance beyond occasional inspections and gutter cleaning. Our quality metal roofing systems withstand decades of harsh weather with minimal deterioration, backed by comprehensive warranties that provide genuine peace of mind.
Premium asphalt shingles from our manufacturer partners offer excellent durability, though they may require periodic repairs for loose or damaged shingles, especially after severe storms common in Minnesota and Wisconsin. Our employee-based service teams provide prompt, professional repairs when needed.
Energy Efficiency and Long-Term Savings
Metal roofs reflect solar radiation effectively, keeping homes cooler during summer months while reducing air conditioning costs. This energy efficiency proves particularly beneficial for homes with significant sun exposure throughout our region’s warm summers.
Some metal roofing products qualify for energy efficiency rebates or tax credits, further offsetting installation costs. Miller’s Roofing & Siding stays current on available incentive programs and helps homeowners maximize their savings opportunities.
Resale Value and Lifetime Investment Returns
Metal roofing typically increases home resale value more than asphalt shingles, with studies suggesting metal roofs can recoup 85% to 95% of their installation cost upon sale. This enhanced resale value, combined with reduced lifetime maintenance and replacement costs, often makes metal roofing the more economical long-term choice.
When calculating lifetime costs, metal roofing’s superior longevity and minimal maintenance requirements frequently offset higher initial investments, especially for homeowners planning extended residence in their current homes.
Expert Guidance from Miller’s Roofing & Siding
Professional Cost Estimates for Your Specific Needs
Miller’s Roofing & Siding provides comprehensive, transparent cost estimates that account for your home’s specific requirements, local climate conditions, and material preferences. Our experienced team evaluates factors like roof complexity, existing conditions, and your long-term goals to recommend the most cost-effective solution.
We use only premium materials from trusted manufacturers like GAF, CertainTeed, Tamko, Owens Corning, EDCO, and Dakota Steel, ensuring maximum value from your investment. Our metal roofing installations feature quality systems specifically designed to withstand Minnesota and Wisconsin’s challenging climate conditions.
Three Decades of Local Expertise
With over 30 years of experience serving Minnesota and Wisconsin homeowners, Miller’s Roofing & Siding understands the unique challenges our climate presents. Our family-owned business prioritizes honest recommendations based on your specific needs rather than pushing the highest-priced option.
We’ll help you understand the true cost comparison between metal roofing and shingles, including long-term maintenance expectations, energy efficiency benefits, warranty coverage, and resale value considerations. Our EPA Lead-Safe certification, comprehensive insurance coverage, and commitment to employee-based installation crews ensure professional service you can trust.
Contact Miller’s Roofing & Siding for Your Free Consultation
Ready to explore whether metal roofing is cheaper than shingles for your specific situation? Miller’s Roofing & Siding offers free, no-obligation estimates that provide detailed cost breakdowns for both metal and shingle roofing systems. Our experienced team will assess your home’s specific requirements and explain how different materials perform in our regional climate.
From Albert Lea and Duluth to Superior and Grand Rapids, we’ve helped thousands of Minnesota and Wisconsin homeowners make informed roofing decisions. Our partnerships with industry-leading manufacturers, commitment to employee-based installation crews, and comprehensive warranties ensure your investment provides decades of reliable protection.
Don’t let roofing decisions overwhelm you. Contact Miller’s Roofing & Siding today to schedule your free consultation and discover which roofing solution offers the best value for your home and budget. We’re committed to helping you protect your most important investment—your home and family’s safety and comfort.
Learn more about our roofing services and see more of our completed projects by visiting our website or calling our experienced team. When you choose Miller’s Roofing & Siding, you’re choosing three decades of local expertise, premium materials, and unmatched customer service.
